There has been much discussion lately on the right wing of British politics about banning the burqa. The appeal of such a band to populists is understandable. Burqa bans have been enacted in a number of European countries such as France, Austria, Denmark and Bulgaria, but is it the right thing for the United Kingdom?
There are two fundamental principles at play in a discussion of this issue which are in tension with each other. These are defending our culture and heritage, and affirming our individual liberty and fundamental freedoms.
Clearly the burqa is an alien item of clothing. It is only worn by women in certain strict sects of Islam such as Wahhabism and Deobandism. Often, women are forced to wear the burqa under threat of punishment beatings or deprivation. This is the case under the rule of the Taliban in Afghanistan. Sometimes, however, women wear a burqa by choice, being devout to what they perceive as the correct way to behave or to protect themselves from sexual advances.
The former is repugnant to our way of life, but the latter is not.
Our principle of individual liberty derives from our understanding of Common Law that has developed in England for over 1000 years. Under Common Law we understand that everything is permissible unless it is specifically prohibited because it causes harm, loss or injury to another living man or living woman. Choosing to wear an item of clothing, even if it is alien, does not cause harm, loss or injury.
Thus, in considering a burka ban we need to understand that although it is alien to our culture, individual liberty is a central facet of our culture under which choice of attire is the premise of the individual and not the premise of the state to prohibit.
A more nuanced approach is therefore necessary. A complete burqa ban would be contrary to individual liberty, but it is necessary for people to show their face in social situations where interaction is necessary and unavoidable. The main example of this is, of course, at work, including professional positions such as a teacher, a lecturer, a doctor, a nurse, a bank clerk, a railway station worker; indeed, most jobs require interaction with other people on some level. In these situations, it should be mandatory to show your face except for health and safety reasons.
It is also necessary to show your face if you are requested to do so by a police officer or if you are entering the country through passport control, for example. No special accommodation should be made in these situations for people who wants to conduct themselves in a manner which is alien to our social customs.
However, if someone is just walking down the street, sitting in the park or lying on a beach and they are not interacting with anybody else then the principle of individual liberty means that choosing to wear a burqa in these situations should be permissible, even though it is alien.
So what legislation should be introduced concerning the burqa? The law should always be general and common to all, so any legislation concerning burqas needs be general, concerning face coverings as a whole, rather than a specific law targeting one item of clothing.
At present face coverings are banned in specific places at specific times on the basis of public order. However, a more general ban on face coverings would curtail individual liberty and in some circumstances would jeopardise health and safety.
A certain political party proposed a ban on face coverings in 2017, but it was so ill thought out that they tied themselves up in knots trying to justify it. Ultimately the policy fell under the ridicule of being forced to concede exceptions, such as helmets when cycling, balaclavas in cold weather, masks for surgeons, gas masks in chemical plants and protective clothing for beekeepers. Today, we may add to this list freedom-loving men and women who do not wish to be surveilled, monitored and recorded by facial recognition technology.
The best course of legislative action at the current time would be a compromise between upholding our customs and upholding individual liberty. Face coverings in general should be outlawed when working with other people, by people accessing services in person, and in situations where a person’s face needs to be seen by an officer for security, but not for blanket facial recognition.
This is a compromise however, and there is no perfect solution to the issue without considering the underlying reason why the use of the burqa is increasing. The burqa is alien to our land and is a symptom of the program of replacement migration. Focussing on the symptom does not fix the root of the problem. The real issue is the replacement migration that has given rise to the issue of the burqa in the first place. Ultimately, it is replacement migration that needs to be halted and reversed, so that the symptom of the burqa disappears without needing to bring in legislation. Any legislation concerning the issue, however, must be carefully considered so that it does not damage our fundamental freedoms or undermine Common Law.




